OpenConstruction Academy
Autentificare / Înregistrare
RO

Teorie înainte de sarcina 4 · 9 min

What an option really saves

Inginerie valorică: structură metalică și pereți tencuiți

După această lecție vei putea

  1. List what an option replaces, what it reduces and what it adds.
  2. Carry a saving in the building works through every percentage row to the cost limit.
  3. Take a redesign fee off the saving, at the same price level.
1 / 4

Replace, reduce, add

A value engineering option is rarely one rate swapped for another. A steel frame replaces a concrete one. Being lighter, it reduces the foundations. Being steel, it adds fire protection that the concrete frame did not need. Price all three, or the saving is overstated.

Exemplu. Illustrative: a saving of 72,000 pounds on the frame, walls and foundations shrinks to 47,000 pounds once the fire protection is paid for.
+£60,0001+£12,0002−£25,0003£47,0004
  • 1 Frame and walls replaced
  • 2 Foundations reduced
  • 3 Fire protection added
  • 4 Saving in the works
2 / 4

Each rate on its own measure

An external wall rate is per m² of wall, not per m² of floor. A frame rate is per m² GIFA. Use each new rate on the quantity its line is already measured on, and the bill does the rest.

Exemplu. A building can have more wall than floor or much less, depending on its shape. A wall rate applied to the floor area gives a saving that has nothing to do with the walls.
3 / 4

The saving runs through the mark-ups

Preliminaries, overheads and profit, risk and inflation are percentages. When the building works go down, every one of those rows goes down with them. The saving that matters to the client is the change at the cost limit, which is larger than the change in the works.

Exemplu. With mark-ups that together add about 30%, £100,000 saved in the works is about 130,000 pounds at the cost limit. In the ERP you read it as the change in «Grand Total».
Saving in the building works
£100,000
The same saving at the cost limit
£130,000 (£100,000 + £30,000)
4 / 4

The redesign fee comes off last

Choosing the option costs the design team time to rework the drawings. That fee is real money for the client and belongs in the comparison. It is outside the building works, so it carries no mark-ups. It is already at tender-date prices, so take it off the saving at the cost limit, which is at the same level.

Exemplu. Taken off the works before the mark-ups, the fee would collect preliminaries, profit and risk it never pays for.

Price option B for a clinic

A different building with simplified mark-ups. Predict each figure, then open the step.

Nu este la scară
Problema
  • GIFA 1,200.00 m². Frame £240.00 per m² GIFA now, £205.00 in option B.
  • External walls 900.00 m² of wall: £390.00 per m² now, £330.00 in option B.
  • Substructure £204,800 now, 5% lower in option B. Fire protection to the steel: 950.00 m² at £28.00 per m².
  • All the percentage rows together multiply the works by 1.32. Redesign fee £25,000, at tender-date prices.
???
  • Frame ?
  • External walls ?
  • Substructure ?
£42,000£54,000
  • Frame £42,000
  • External walls £54,000
  • Substructure £10,240
Pasul 1 din 4

Replaced and reduced

Frame and walls at the new rates, foundations lighter. How much do the works save before anything is added?

Frame (£240.00 − £205.00) × 1,200.00 m² = £42,000. Walls (£390.00 − £330.00) × 900.00 m² = £54,000. Substructure 5% of £204,800 = £10,240. Together £106,240.

£106,2401?2?3
  • 1 Replaced and reduced
  • 2 Fire protection
  • 3 Net saving
£106,2401−£26,6002£79,6403
  • 1 Replaced and reduced
  • 2 Fire protection
  • 3 Net saving
Pasul 2 din 4

Net saving in the works

Now pay for the fire protection the steel needs. What is the net saving in the building works?

Fire protection 950.00 m² × £28.00 = £26,600. Net saving £106,240 − £26,600 = £79,640.

Saving in the works
£79,640
Saving at the cost limit
?
Saving in the works
£79,640
Saving at the cost limit
£105,125 (£79,640 + £25,485)
Pasul 3 din 4

At the cost limit

Carry the net saving through the percentage rows. What is it at the cost limit?

£79,640 × 1.32 = £105,125. In the task you read this as the old grand total less the new one.

£105,1251−£25,0002?3
  • 1 Saving at the cost limit
  • 2 Redesign fee
  • 3 Real saving
£105,1251−£25,0002£80,1253
  • 1 Saving at the cost limit
  • 2 Redesign fee
  • 3 Real saving
Pasul 4 din 4

After the redesign fee

The design team's rework is a cost of choosing option B. What does the client really save?

£105,125 − £25,000 = £80,125. This is the figure the client decides on.

Pe scurt. Price what the option replaces, reduces and adds; let the percentage rows carry the saving to the cost limit; take the fee off last.

Verifică-te

Întrebarea 1 din 3

An option saves £50,000 in the building works. The percentage rows together multiply the works by 1.30. The redesign fee is £12,000 at tender-date prices. What does the client really save?

£50,000 × 1.30 = £65,000 at the cost limit. Less the £12,000 fee: £53,000.
Întrebarea 2 din 3

Option B swaps a concrete frame for a steel one. Which change is easiest to forget?

  • That is the change the option is about. Nobody forgets it.

  • Concrete protects itself; steel does not. The protection is a cost option B adds.

  • The cost plan is without VAT, so VAT plays no part here.

Întrebarea 3 din 3

The new external wall rate is per m² of wall. Which quantity do you multiply it by?

  • GIFA is floor. The wall line is measured in m² of wall.

  • Change the rate, keep the line's own quantity.

  • The footprint is the substructure measure, not the walls.