OpenConstruction Academy
Logga in / Registrera
SV

Teori före uppgift 5 · 9 min

Valuing a change of bar size

Revision C: mät om ändringen

Efter den här lektionen kan du

  1. Say why a revised drawing issued with an instruction is a variation, and how it is valued.
  2. Omit the old bars and add the new ones, with the new cut lengths.
  3. Price a size that is not in the bill with a new rate built like the others.
1 / 5

A revised drawing is a change to the works

  • The Engineer issues a new revision with an instruction.
  • Under the Red Book that instruction is a variation.
  • It is measured and valued, then the contract price moves.

FIDIC Red Book 2017 deals with variations in Clause 13, and its measurement and valuation clause says how they are valued. The work is valued at the rates in the contract where they apply, and at a new rate where none does.

2 / 5

A change of size comes out and goes in

  • The old bars leave the structure: omit them.
  • The new bars are built: add them.
  • The variation is the difference, never the new bars alone.
−AED 4,2001+AED 6,5002AED 2,3003
  • 1 Old bars out
  • 2 New bars in
  • 3 Net change

Illustrative figures in AED. Valuing only the added bars pays for the old steel twice: once in the bill and once in the variation.

3 / 5

A new size means a new cut length

  • Same outside dimensions do not mean the same bar.
  • A bigger bar bends on a bigger former and loses more length.
  • A thicker link needs a longer hook tail, 10d.
T16, former 4d: r + 2d (mm)64
T50, former 7d: r + 2d (mm)275

Work out each new mark from its shape code again, exactly as in task 1. Copying the old cut length gives the wrong weight.

4 / 5

Which rate for which bar

  • Sizes the bill already prices keep their bill rates.
  • A new size gets a rate from the same parts: supply, waste, cutting, fixing.
  • The markup of the bill applies to the variation too.
Size in the billBill rate
Size not in the billNew rate, built like the bill rates
Overhead and profitAs the bill: once, on the net value
VATNot in the value; it goes on the invoice

A new rate built the same way as the bill's is easy for the Engineer to check, and hard to argue with.

5 / 5

Three questions before you raise the order

  • Which elements does the instruction change, and how many of them?
  • Did I omit every old mark and add every new one?
  • Is each size at its bill rate, with one markup and no VAT?

Most disputed variations fail one of these: the wrong count of elements, an add without its omit, or a rate nobody can trace.

Piltangenter eller svep

Value a change from T40 to T50

A different instruction from your task. Weights in kg; the value in AED.

Inte skalenlig
Uppgiften
  • Instruction: on 10 transfer beams, 3 T40 straight bars of 6.0 m become 3 T50, same length.
  • Mass per metre: T40 9.877 kg, T50 15.432 kg. Weights per beam to 0.01 kg, then tonnes to 3 decimals.
  • Bill rate for T40 AED 3,685.00 per tonne. T50 is not in the bill: supply AED 2,700.00 with 5 % waste, cut and bend AED 340.00, fix AED 430.00.
  • Overhead and profit 10% on the net value, as in the bill.
T40 out (kg)
?
T40 out (kg)
1,777.9
Steg 1 av 5

Weight omitted

3 bars × 6.0 m × T40 kg per metre, per beam, times 10. How many kg come out?

3 × 6.0 × 9.877 = 177.79 kg a beam. × 10 = 1,777.9 kg, so 1.778 t omitted.

T40 out (kg)
1,777.9
T50 in (kg)
?
T40 out (kg)
1,777.9
T50 in (kg)
2,777.8
Steg 2 av 5

Weight added

The same for the T50 bars. How many kg go in?

3 × 6.0 × 15.432 = 277.78 kg a beam. × 10 = 2,777.8 kg, so 2.778 t added.

AED 2,835
  • Supply with waste AED 2,835
  • Cut and bend AED 340
  • Fix AED 430
AED 2,835
  • Supply with waste AED 2,835
  • Cut and bend AED 340
  • Fix AED 430
Steg 3 av 5

A new rate for T50

Built like the bill rates. What is the T50 rate per net tonne?

AED 2,700.00 × 1.05 + AED 340.00 + AED 430.00 = AED 3,605.00.

+AED 10,0151−AED 6,5522?3
  • 1 T50 in
  • 2 T40 out
  • 3 Net value
+AED 10,0151−AED 6,5522AED 3,4633
  • 1 T50 in
  • 2 T40 out
  • 3 Net value
Steg 4 av 5

Net value

Tonnes added at the new rate, less tonnes omitted at the bill rate. What is the net value?

2.778 × AED 3,605.00 − 1.778 × AED 3,685.00 = AED 3,462.76.

AED 3,4631?2?3
  • 1 Net value
  • 2 Overhead and profit
  • 3 Variation
AED 3,4631+AED 3462AED 3,8093
  • 1 Net value
  • 2 Overhead and profit
  • 3 Variation
Steg 5 av 5

The variation value

Add the bill's overhead and profit. No VAT. What is the value of the variation?

AED 3,462.76 × 1.10 = AED 3,809.04. This is the estimated cost impact you put on the variation request.

Kort sagt. Re-measure each changed mark, omit the old and add the new, price each size at its rate, then one markup and no VAT.

Testa dig själv

Fråga 1 av 3

An instruction adds bars worth AED 15,000.00 at the bill rates and omits bars worth AED 6,000.00. Overhead and profit are 10 % on the net value. What is the variation, without VAT?

15,000 − 6,000 = 9,000. × 1.10 = AED 9,900.00.
Fråga 2 av 3

Links change from T8 to T10 with the same outside dimensions and spacing. What happens to the cut length of one link?

  • Same outside dimensions, but a longer hook tail (10d) and a bigger bend deduction.

  • Each hook tail is 10d, so both tails grow with the bar. Together they add more than the bigger bends take back.

  • The bends take a little more back, but the two longer tails add more than that.

Fråga 3 av 3

The instruction changes the beams on two of the four floors. How many beams do you re-measure, if there are 11 on each floor?

  • That is one floor.

  • Only the floors named in the instruction change: 2 × 11.

  • That is every floor. The other beams are unchanged.