Valuing a contract instruction under JBCC clause 26.2
ایک کنٹریکٹ ہدایت کی قیمت لگائیں
اس لیکچر کے بعد آپ کر سکیں گے
Find the right valuation rule for each part of an instruction: bill rate, adjusted rate, or cost plus 10 %.
Value a change of specification as an omission plus an addition.
Total the instruction excluding VAT.
1 / 3
Who may change the work
Under the JBCC PBA the principal agent may issue a contract instruction that alters the design, the standard or the quantity of the works (clause 17.1.2). The contractor must carry it out. What it is worth is a separate question, answered by clause 26.2, and the quantity surveyor prepares that valuation for the principal agent.
مثال. An instruction changes the works first and the money second. The valuation follows rules, not negotiation.
2 / 3
The order of the valuation rules
Clause 26.2 is a ladder, taken from the top. Work similar to billed work, done under similar conditions, is valued at the bill rates. Work not quite similar is valued at rates adjusted from the bill. Only where neither fits is the work valued at cost plus 10 %, the percentage covering overheads and profit. Omitted work is valued at bill rates. The ladder protects both sides: the contractor keeps its tendered pricing level, and the employer does not pay cost plus for work the bill already prices.
مثال. Changing 30 m² of plaster to a billed tiled finish is valued at the bill rates. A burglar bar with no similar item goes to cost plus 10 %.
3 / 3
A change of specification is two lines
When an instruction replaces one billed item with another, value it as what it is: omit the old work at its bill rate, add the new work at its bill rate. The net change is the difference in rates times the quantity. Writing it as two lines keeps the variation order traceable to the bill.
مثال. Omit 85 m² at R 230.00, add 85 m² at R 310.00: net 85 × 80.00.
Omit, old ceiling−R 19,550.00
Add, new ceilingR 26,350.00
Net changeR 6,800.00
Value an instruction with two parts
An instruction changes a ceiling type in the bill and adds burglar bars to a store window. The bill has both ceiling types but nothing like the bars.
پیمانے کے مطابق نہیں
مسئلہ
Ceiling: 85 m² of the billed gypsum ceiling at R 230.00 per m² becomes the billed suspended ceiling at R 310.00 per m².
Burglar bars: no similar bill item. Checked cost: labour R 1,350.00, materials R 2,900.00.
Values exclude VAT.
مرحلہ 1 از 4
Omission
Omitted work is valued at bill rates. What is the omission?
اشارہ: Quantity × old rate.
85 × R 230.00 = R 19,550.00 omitted.
مرحلہ 2 از 4
Net change for the ceiling
Add the new ceiling at its bill rate and take off the omission. What is the net change?
اشارہ: New value less omitted value.
85 × R 310.00 − R 19,550.00 = R 6,800.00.
مرحلہ 3 از 4
Burglar bars at cost plus 10 %
No similar item. What are the bars worth?
اشارہ: Labour plus materials, then 10 %.
(R 1,350.00 + R 2,900.00) × 1.10 = R 4,675.00.
R 6,800R 4,675
Ceiling, net R 6,800
Bars, cost + 10 % R 4,675
R 6,800R 4,675
Ceiling, net R 6,800
Bars, cost + 10 % R 4,675
مرحلہ 4 از 4
Value of the instruction
Add both parts. What is the instruction worth, excluding VAT?
اشارہ: Two results.
R 6,800.00 + R 4,675.00 = R 11,475.00.
مختصراً. Climb clause 26.2 from the top: bill rate, adjusted rate, then cost plus 10 %. Changes of specification are an omission and an addition.
خود کو جانچیں
سوال 1 از 3
Instructed work has no similar bill item. Checked cost: labour R 1,800.00, materials R 4,200.00. What is it worth, excluding VAT?
(1,800.00 + 4,200.00) × 1.10 = R 6,600.00.
سوال 2 از 3
The bill has an item for the same work done under similar conditions. How is the instructed work valued?
Right. That is the first rung of clause 26.2.
Cost plus is the last rung, for work with nothing similar in the bill.
The contract sets the rule; a quote is not needed.
سوال 3 از 3
An instruction replaces billed half-brick walls with billed one-brick walls. What is the correct valuation?
The half-brick walls are not built any more; their value must be omitted.
Right. The net is the rate difference times the area.