OpenConstruction Academy
Log ind / Tilmeld
DA

Teori før opgave 5 · 10 min

Substantial performance and releasing the holdback

Væsentlig færdiggørelse og frigivelse af tilbageholdelsen

Efter dette foredrag kan du

  1. Apply the sliding threshold in s. 2 (1) of the Construction Act to the adjusted contract price.
  2. Know what publication of the certificate starts: the 60-day lien period.
  3. Release the holdback with its HST.
1 / 3

A sliding threshold, not a single percentage

Under the Construction Act, s. 2 (1), a contract is substantially performed when the work is ready for use or being used for its purpose and what is left can be completed or corrected for no more than 3 per cent of the first $1,000,000 of the contract price, 2 per cent of the next $1,000,000 and 1 per cent of the balance. Use the price as adjusted by change orders. Applying 3 per cent to the whole price overstates the threshold on any contract above a million.

Eksempel. On $3,486,500.00: 30,000 + 20,000 + 1 % × 1,486,500 = $64,865.00.
3 % of the first million$30,000.00
2 % of the second million$20,000.00
1 % of the balance$14,865.00
Threshold$64,865.00
2 / 3

Publication starts the lien clock

Once the consultant certifies substantial performance, the certificate is published. A contractor's lien for work up to that date expires at the end of 60 days after publication (s. 31 (2) (a)), unless the contract is completed, abandoned or terminated earlier. When all liens have expired or been dealt with, the holdback must be paid: the owner pays the contractor no later than 14 days after that (s. 26 (8)), and each payer down the chain within 14 days of receiving it.

Eksempel. Published on a Wednesday: count 60 days, then up to 14 more for the owner to pay.
3 / 3

Releasing the holdback with its tax

The holdback held at publication is 10 per cent of everything certified, excluding HST: the adjusted price less the work still to do. The HST on it, deferred at each claim, now becomes payable (Excise Tax Act, s. 168 (7)), so the release invoice adds 13 per cent.

$344,530
  • Holdback $344,530
  • HST on release $44,789

Test a building and release its fund

A library is in use. The consultant is about to certify substantial performance.

Ikke i målestok
Opgaven
  • Contract price $3,400,000.00 excluding HST; change orders add $86,500.00.
  • Incomplete and deficient work at publication: $41,200.00.
  • Holdback 10%; HST 13%.
Trin 1 af 4

Threshold

3 % of the first million, 2 % of the second, 1 % of the rest of the adjusted price. What is the threshold?

30,000.00 + 20,000.00 + ($3,400,000.00 + $86,500.00 − 2,000,000.00) × 1 % = $64,865.00.

Trin 2 af 4

Room under the threshold

Threshold less the work left. How much room is there?

$64,865.00 − $41,200.00 = $23,665.00: substantially performed.

Trin 3 af 4

Holdback held

Holdback on the adjusted price less the work left. How much is held?

($3,400,000.00 + $86,500.00 − $41,200.00) × 10% = $344,530.00.

$344,530
  • Holdback $344,530
  • HST $44,789
$344,530
  • Holdback $344,530
  • HST $44,789
Trin 4 af 4

Release with HST

Add the deferred HST. What is released?

$344,530.00 × 1.13 = $389,318.90.

Kort sagt. Slice the adjusted price 3/2/1; compare the work left; release the holdback on what was certified, plus its HST, after the lien period.

Test dig selv

Spørgsmål 1 af 3

The adjusted contract price is $1,600,000.00. What is the substantial performance threshold?

3 % × 1,000,000 + 2 % × 600,000 = $42,000.00.
Spørgsmål 2 af 3

A certificate of substantial performance is published. What runs out 60 days later?

  • The owner pays after liens have expired, within a further period.

  • Right: s. 31 (2) (a).

  • Warranty periods come from the contract, not this section.

Spørgsmål 3 af 3

On the release invoice, HST is charged on the holdback because…

  • It is the same supply; only the tax was deferred.

  • Right: Excise Tax Act, s. 168 (7).

  • The tax timing comes from the statute.