Retention, the security cap and what is actually paid
עירבון, ערובה ומה שבאמת לתשלום
אחרי ההרצאה הזו תוכלו
Take retention from the value of the work excluding GST.
Charge GST on the full value, not on the value after retention.
Track how much retention is still to come before the security cap is reached.
1 / 3
Retention is security, not a discount
AS 4000 lets the parties choose in the Annexure how the contractor gives security: cash, bank guarantees, or retention moneys held back from each progress payment. Retention is a share of the value of the work, excluding GST, held by the Principal until it is released. The work was still done in full, so it stays taxable in full.
דוגמה. The ERP's net due works the same way: value excluding GST, less retention. GST is not in it yet.
Value of work, excluding GST$240,000
Retention, 5 %$12,000
Due after retention$228,000
2 / 3
The cap
The Annexure also sets how much security the Principal may hold in all, as a share of the contract sum, and often a lower share after practical completion. Retention stops once the cap is reached. Whether the cap is on the original contract sum or on the sum adjusted by variations is a contract choice; read the Annexure and the instrument of agreement.
דוגמה. A cap of $185,000.00: held $94,210.40, this claim $13,840.25, still to deduct $76,949.35.
$94,210$76,949
Held after earlier claims $94,210
Held on this claim $13,840
Still to deduct $76,949
3 / 3
What the Principal pays
The amount payable is the value excluding GST, less retention, plus GST on the full value. Taking GST on the value after retention understates the tax invoice; taking retention on the GST-inclusive total holds back tax that was never part of the security.
דוגמה. On $240,000.00 at 5 % retention: $240,000.00 − $12,000.00 + $24,000.00.
1 Value, excluding GST
2 Retention
3 GST on the full value
4 Payable
Settle a claim
Another contract, claim 4. The Annexure there: retention 5 % of each payment, to a cap of 5 % of the contract sum in the agreement.
לא בקנה מידה
הבעיה
Claim 4, excluding GST: $236,480.40.
Retention 5% of each payment. Cap 5% of the contract sum $3,640,000.
Retention held after claim 3: $64,212.55. GST one tenth.
Value, excluding GST$236,480.40
Retention?
Value, excluding GST$236,480.40
Retention$11,824.02
שלב 1 מתוך 4
Retention
Take the retention from the value excluding GST. How much is held on claim 4?
רמז: Value excluding GST times the rate.
$236,480.40 × 5% = $11,824.02.
שלב 2 מתוך 4
Net due, as the ERP shows it
Value excluding GST, less retention. What is the net due?
רמז: No GST in this figure.
$236,480.40 − $11,824.02 = $224,656.38.
1 Value
2 Retention
3 GST
4 Payable
1 Value
2 Retention
3 GST
4 Payable
שלב 3 מתוך 4
Amount payable
Add GST on the full value. What is payable on claim 4?
רמז: GST on the value excluding GST, not on the net due.
GST on the full value is $23,648.04. $224,656.38 + $23,648.04 = $248,304.42.
$64,213$11,824?
Held before $64,213
Claim 4 $11,824
Still to deduct ?
$64,213$105,963
Held before $64,213
Claim 4 $11,824
Still to deduct $105,963
שלב 4 מתוך 4
Retention still to come
Cap less everything held so far. How much retention is still to be deducted?
רמז: Held after claim 3 and held on claim 4 both count.
Cap $182,000.00. Less $64,212.55 and $11,824.02: $105,963.43 still to deduct.
בקצרה. Retention off the value, GST on the full value, and the cap counts every dollar held so far.
בדקו את עצמכם
שאלה 1 מתוך 3
Retention is 5 % of each payment. On which figure is it taken?
That holds back tax as security. The base is the value of the work.
Security is held against the work, not the tax.
Each claim's retention is on its own value.
The contract sum sets the cap, not each deduction.
שאלה 2 מתוך 3
The cap is a share of the contract sum. Variations have raised the sum since the agreement. Which sum sets the cap?
That depends on the contract, not a general rule.
Read them. In this course it is the sum in the instrument of agreement.
Claimed value is not the contract sum.
Variations do not remove the cap.
שאלה 3 מתוך 3
A claim of $180,000.00 excluding GST. Retention 5 %, GST one tenth. What is payable?