OpenConstruction Academy
Inloggen / Registreren
NL

Theorie vóór opdracht 1 · 10 min

Rate analysis: what one unit of work consumes, priced at site

Metselwerk: de goedkopere bron, daarna de kosten per m3

Inleiding tot de cursus

Na deze les kunt u

  1. Read an analysis sheet: quantity basis, coefficients, basic rates and W.
  2. Compare two material offers at the same place, on site, and keep the cheaper delivered cost.
  3. Turn the cost of the sheet quantity into a rate per measured unit.
1 / 3

Why a rate needs an analysis

In Indian public works a bill rate is not a guess. Each rate in the CPWD Delhi Schedule of Rates, and in the state schedules that copy its method, rests on an analysis of rates: a sheet listing what a stated quantity of the work consumes in materials, labour and sundries, each at a basic rate. The sum of those lines, before any percentage, is the cost W. A rate you cannot trace back to such a sheet will not survive the scrutiny of a public works estimate.

Voorbeeld. Basic rates in a schedule are exclusive of GST and of the contractor's profit and overheads. Those are added later, each in its own step, so W stays a clean cost.
2 / 3

Compare materials where they are used: on site

Every rate in an analysis is a rate at the work site. A material quoted at the source (a kiln, a quarry) still has to travel the lead, the haul distance, and the carriage has to be paid. A material quoted delivered already carries that cost. So you compare offers only after both are on site: gate price plus carriage against the delivered price. The cheaper gate price often loses.

Voorbeeld. Stone at the quarry costs 1,300 per m³ and the haul adds 380; a dealer delivers it for 1,640. Delivered, the quarry costs more, so the dealer wins.
Quarry, on site
₹1,680 (₹1,300 + ₹380)
Dealer, delivered
₹1,640
3 / 3

Analysed for 10 m³, billed per m³

IS 1200, the Indian standard method of measurement, measures brickwork and stone masonry of one brick thickness and more by volume, in m³. Analysis sheets are often written for 10 m³ so that the coefficients stay readable: 5,000 bricks rather than 500, 7 mason-days rather than 0.7. The bill, however, pays per m³. Divide W by the sheet quantity before the rate goes anywhere near the bill.

Voorbeeld. A sheet that costs 50,560.00 for 10 m³ gives 5,056.00 per m³. Typing 50,560.00 as a unit rate overprices the line tenfold.

Analyse 10 m³ of stone masonry

Random rubble masonry in cement mortar, analysed for 10 m³. Choose the cheaper stone on site, then find W and the cost per m³.

Niet op schaal
De opgave
  • Stone needed: 11 m³. Quarry: ₹1,300.00 per m³ at the gate, carriage ₹380.00 per m³. Dealer: ₹1,640.00 per m³ delivered.
  • Cement ₹7,030.00, sand ₹5,780.00, labour (mason, beldar, bhisti) ₹18,910.00, scaffolding and sundries ₹800.00.
  • The sheet is for 10 m³.
Quarry
₹1,680 (₹1,300 + ₹380)
Dealer
₹1,640
Quarry
₹1,680 (₹1,300 + ₹380)
Dealer
₹1,640
Stap 1 van 4

Quarry stone on site

Gate price plus carriage. What does a m³ of quarry stone cost on site?

₹1,300.00 + ₹380.00 = ₹1,680.00 per m³ on site, which is more than the dealer's ₹1,640.00.

Stap 2 van 4

Cost of the stone

Take the cheaper delivered rate. What do the 11 m³ of stone cost?

11 × ₹1,640.00 = ₹18,040.00. The dealer's rate already includes delivery, so no carriage line is added.

₹18,040₹12,810₹18,910
  • Stone ₹18,040
  • Cement and sand ₹12,810
  • Labour ₹18,910
  • Sundries ₹800
₹18,040₹12,810₹18,910
  • Stone ₹18,040
  • Cement and sand ₹12,810
  • Labour ₹18,910
  • Sundries ₹800
Stap 3 van 4

W for 10 m³

Add stone, cement, sand, labour and sundries. What is W?

₹18,040.00 + ₹7,030.00 + ₹5,780.00 + ₹18,910.00 + ₹800.00 = ₹50,560.00.

Stap 4 van 4

Cost per m³

The bill measures masonry per m³. What is W per m³?

₹50,560.00 ÷ 10 = ₹5,056.00 per m³. Still a cost: water charges and profit come next.

Kort gezegd. Price every material on site, add the sheet lines into W, and divide by the sheet quantity. Only then is it a cost per unit of the bill.

Test uzelf

Vraag 1 van 3

A kiln quotes bricks lower than a town depot. When does the kiln offer win?

  • The kiln price is at the gate. Without the haul it is not comparable.

  • Right. Both offers have to be compared on site.

  • Any lead costs money. The test is the delivered price, not a distance limit.

Vraag 2 van 3

A depot's price is delivered to site. Do you add a carriage line for it in the analysis?

  • Only for materials priced at the source.

  • Right. A second carriage line would pay delivery twice.

  • There is no half-lead rule. Delivered means carriage is inside the price.

Vraag 3 van 3

A plaster analysis for 10 m² comes to W = 3,240.00. What is W per m²?

3,240.00 ÷ 10 = 324.00 per m².