A change on the critical path: fragnet and time impact analysis
O modificare a beneficiarului pe drumul critic: fragnetul
După această lecție vei putea
Model a change as a fragnet: take out deleted work, add the new activity, link it where it sits.
Measure the delay as the move of Substantial Completion on the current update.
Convert a delay in working days into an extension in calendar days under A201-2017.
1 / 3
Time impact analysis in four moves
A prospective time impact analysis, as AACE International describes it in its recommended practice, measures a change before it is built. Take the current schedule update. Remove the work the change deletes. Insert a fragnet, a small network of the new work. Run the critical path and compare the finish with the finish before. The difference is the delay the change causes.
Exemplu. On a critical activity the deleted day comes off and the fragnet's days go on: the finish moves by 3 working days.
1 Planned length before
2 Deleted work
3 Fragnet
4 Planned length after
2 / 3
Link the fragnet where the work sits
The links of a fragnet come from the building, not from convenience. Ask what physically has to be in place before the new work, and what cannot start until it is done. A fragnet hung beside the next activity, with nothing waiting for it, hides its own delay. The architect checks the logic, so put it on the change order backup.
Exemplu. Hung beside the next activity, the same change even shortens the job by the deleted day. That is the logic hiding the delay, not a saving.
Linked in series, as built
73
Hung beside the next activity
69
3 / 3
Working days to calendar days
The schedule measures the delay in working days. A201-2017 Section 8.1.4 makes a day in the Contract Documents a calendar day unless otherwise defined, so the Contract Time is adjusted in calendar days. Find the old and the new finish on a calendar and count the days between them, weekends included.
Exemplu. Six working days cross one weekend: the extension is 6 + 2 calendar days.
Substantial Completion beforeWednesday, March 31, 2027
Delay, working days6
Substantial Completion afterThursday, April 8, 2027
Extension, calendar days8
Lead-lined walls in two X-ray rooms
Another job, a medical office. The owner's change order replaces standard drywall in two X-ray rooms with lead-lined board.
Nu este la scară
Problema
Lead-lined board: 2,700 sq ft, the installer sets 360 sq ft a day.
Ground-floor drywall, 6 working days, is critical. The change deletes 1 day of standard board in it.
The board goes on after the drywall and before tape and finish.
Planned length before the change: 62. The next longest path: 57.
Substantial Completion before the change: Tuesday, March 2, 2027.
Lead-lined board, sq ft2,700
Output per day, sq ft360
Duration, working days?
Lead-lined board, sq ft2,700
Output per day, sq ft360
Duration, working days8
Pasul 1 din 4
Fragnet duration
What is the duration of the lead-lined board activity?
Indiciu: Quantity over output, rounded up.
2,700 ÷ 360 = 7.5 days. Round up: 8 working days.
Pasul 2 din 4
Deleted work out first
What is the new duration of the ground-floor drywall?
Indiciu: Take out what the change deletes before you add anything.
6 − 1 = 5 working days. Left in, the deleted board would add a day the owner does not owe.
1 Length before
2 Standard board deleted
3 Lead-lined fragnet
4 Length after
1 Length before
2 Standard board deleted
3 Lead-lined fragnet
4 Length after
Pasul 3 din 4
New planned length
The fragnet sits between drywall and tape and finish. What is the planned length now?
Indiciu: The path through the drywall loses one day and gains the fragnet. Check it is still the longest.
62 − 1 + 8 = 69, longer than the next path at 57. The delay is 69 − 62 working days.
Pasul 4 din 4
Extension in calendar days
Substantial Completion was Tuesday, March 2, 2027. What extension in calendar days does the change order state?
Indiciu: Count the working days forward on a calendar, then count every day between the two dates.
7 working days from Tuesday end on Thursday, March 11, 2027. One weekend lies between: 9 calendar days.
Pe scurt. Take out what the change deletes, link the fragnet where the work sits, measure the move of the finish and state it in calendar days.
Verifică-te
Întrebarea 1 din 3
A fragnet moves Substantial Completion by 5 working days. The old finish was Wednesday, March 3, 2027. What extension in calendar days does the change order state?
Five working days from a Wednesday end on the Wednesday a week later: 7 calendar days.
Întrebarea 2 din 3
A change replaces vinyl flooring, already one day of the flooring activity, with sealed concrete. What comes first in the fragnet?
Right. Deleted work leaves the schedule first, or the analysis counts it twice.
The owner would pay for a day of work that no longer exists.
A fragnet goes where the work sits. Days at the end skip the logic and the float.
Întrebarea 3 din 3
A new activity is added but nothing waits for it to finish. What does the analysis show?
Right. Without a successor the fragnet floats and hides its own delay.
Being in the schedule is not enough. The links decide what it moves.
With no successor nothing is pushed. Link it to what physically follows.