OpenConstruction Academy
เข้าสู่ระบบ / สมัครสมาชิก
TH

ทฤษฎีก่อนงานที่ 3 · 10 นาที

Comparing bids like with like

ปรับเกลี่ยใบเสนอราคา dry lining และมอบงาน

หลังจบบทเรียนนี้ คุณจะสามารถ

  1. Explain why the headline totals of three bids cannot be compared.
  2. Level a bid that has a gap by pricing the missing scope with a stated rule.
  3. Tell an estimate from an offer, and award with a written reason.
1 / 4

Three bids, three different jobs

Bidders price what they understood and what they chose to include. A lower total may simply buy less. Before you compare totals, compare scope: has every line been priced? Are quantities the ones you issued? Does the bidder qualify the offer, for instance 'excluding the shaft walls'?

ตัวอย่าง. Y looks cheapest by 5,940 pounds. Whether it really is cheapest is a different question, and this is how it is answered.
Bidder X, all three lines priced
£42,940
Bidder Y, one line left blank
£37,000
Bidder Z, all three lines priced
£45,160
2 / 4

Three kinds of gap

An omission: a line is blank, perhaps by mistake. An exclusion: the bidder states it will not do part of the scope. A qualification: the bid is priced, but on conditions that change the risk, such as a different programme. Each one has to be resolved before the bid can be called complete. Ask the bidder first; do not guess whether a blank was a slip or a decision.

ตัวอย่าง. A blank may mean 'forgot', 'included elsewhere' or 'we do not do this'. The three have different consequences for the award.
3 / 4

Levelling: pricing the gap

Levelling adds a stated price for the missing scope so that bids can be compared. The rule is a judgement. The highest rate received is cautious and favours complete bids least. The lowest is optimistic. The average smooths. Your own estimate keeps you consistent with your budget but may not be fair to the bidder. Choose a rule before you open the bids and apply it to every bid.

ตัวอย่าง. For 40 units the gap is priced at 3,360 to 3,760 pounds, depending on the rule. The range is the uncertainty you are carrying. Write the rule down.
Lowest rate received£3,360
Average rate received£3,520
Highest rate received£3,760
Your own estimate£3,200
4 / 4

A levelled sum is not an offer

A levelled total is your estimate of what the bid would cost if it were complete. The bidder never offered it. A contract is formed on an offer, so you cannot award on a figure the bidder has not made. If the gap is an exclusion, the excluded work must be bought elsewhere, and the interface between two firms on one wall is a coordination risk. Award to the lowest complete, compliant bid, and write the reason down: it is your audit trail.

ตัวอย่าง. Where a fire-rated wall meets the slab, one firm builds the wall and another seals the joint. If the two do not agree who closes the gap, nobody does.
Cutaway of a vertical service shaft with fire-rated walls and a sealed joint highlighted where each wall meets a floor slab.

Level Bidder Y and compare

Three lines are in the package. Bidder Y left line C blank. Work out what Y would cost if complete, and see what that means.

ไม่ได้วาดตามมาตราส่วน
โจทย์
  • Quantities: A 800 m², B 600 m², C 40 m².
  • X priced A £31.00, B £24.50, C £86.00. Z priced A £33.00, B £25.00, C £94.00.
  • Y priced A £29.00 and B £23.00. Line C is blank.
  • The rule: price a gap at the highest rate received for that line.
Bidder Y as recorded
?
Bidder Y as recorded
£37,000
ขั้นตอนที่ 1 จาก 4

What Y has priced

Y's recorded total: lines A and B only. Round to the nearest pound.

A: 800 × £29.00; B: 600 × £23.00. Together £37,000. That is the figure Y put in, not the cost of the package.

Bidder Y as recorded, plus the gap
?
Bidder Y as recorded, plus the gap
£40,760 (£37,000 + £3,760)
ขั้นตอนที่ 2 จาก 4

Price the gap

The highest rate received for line C, times the quantity. What does the gap come to?

X priced C at £86.00 and Z at £94.00. The highest is £94.00. 40 × £94.00 = £3,760.

Bidder Y levelled
£40,760 (£37,000 + £3,760)
Bidder Y levelled
£40,760 (£37,000 + £3,760)
ขั้นตอนที่ 3 จาก 4

Y levelled

Add the gap to Y's recorded total. What is Y's levelled total?

£37,000 + £3,760 = £40,760. This is your estimate of a complete Y. It is not something Y has offered.

Bidder Y levelled
£40,760 (£37,000 + £3,760)
Bidder X, complete
?
Bidder Y levelled
£40,760 (£37,000 + £3,760)
Bidder X, complete
£42,940
ขั้นตอนที่ 4 จาก 4

What certainty costs

X is the lowest complete bid: A 800 × £31.00, B 600 × £24.50, C 40 × £86.00. How far is X above Y levelled?

X: £42,940. Y levelled: £40,760. The difference is £2,180. That is the price of a bid that is complete, offered, and binding on one firm.

สรุปสั้น ๆ. Y is still lowest after levelling, and still not the one to award: the levelled sum is your estimate, not Y's offer. Award X, and write the reason.

ทดสอบตัวเอง

คำถามที่ 1 จาก 3

A bidder has left one line blank. What is the first thing to do?

  • That rewards the gap: the bid looks cheaper because it does less.

  • The answer decides whether the bid can be completed. Record it in writing.

  • Levelling is for comparison. You cannot award on a price the bidder never gave.

  • A blank may be a slip. Your tender rules decide, but asking first is normally fair and cheap.

คำถามที่ 2 จาก 3

A bid records £10,000. Line D, 30 units, is blank. The other bids priced line D at £40.00 and £52.00 per unit. Your rule is the average rate received. What is the levelled total?

Average rate (40 + 52) ÷ 2 = 46. Gap 30 × 46 = 1,380. Levelled total: £11,380.
คำถามที่ 3 จาก 3

After levelling, the incomplete bid is still the lowest. Why not award it?

  • A contract needs an offer. Y never offered to do line C at that price, or at all.

  • Not always. Here it stays lowest, and it still cannot be awarded as it stands.

  • The rule is about the offer, not about software.

  • Then the gap is bought at whatever price the bidder names after it has won.