OpenConstruction Academy
Sign in / Register
EN

Theory before task 2 · 10 min

Work with no position: check the scope, not the bill

What the report cannot find: work with no position

After this lecture you can

  1. Explain why a check that compares the bill with itself cannot find work that has no position.
  2. Check completeness the other way round: from every scope item of the specification to a position.
  3. Add a missing position with the measured quantity and the list rate, and read what it adds.
1 / 3

The gap that no report can see

A tool that reads the bill compares positions with positions: it finds repeats, odd rates and strange units. Work that is missing has no position, so there is nothing to compare. The defence is a different direction of checking. You start from the specification, which lists what the client wants built, and tick each scope item against the bill. An item with no tick is a hole in the price, and the bidder who leaves it out wins on price and loses on the job.

Example. Completeness runs from the specification to the bill. Correctness runs from the bill to the drawings. You need both.
2 / 3

How to tick off scope

Number the scope items, then go through the bill and write the position number next to each. Look for work by what it is, not by what the position is called: earthing under a foundation may sit in the electrical title or the groundwork title. When two scope items are met by one position, check that its description names both. Items that cannot be found are listed with their reference and sent to whoever owns the bill. Only then do you price.

Example. A position can exist but cover less than the scope: 'insulation to external walls' when the specification also asks for the plinth. Read the words, not the heading.
3 / 3

Pricing the new position

Quantity from the measurement schedule, not from the drawing by eye: the schedule is the agreed measurement and the client can check it. Rate from the firm's unit-price list in the edition for this tender, as it is net. Unit as in the schedule, so that quantity and rate agree. The value is quantity times rate. Add it to the right title with a new number that does not disturb the existing ones, and read the title total, which should rise by exactly that value.

Example. If the specification and the measurement schedule disagree, do not choose silently: note it and raise it.

Find the gap and price it

Different numbers from your task.

Not to scale
The problem
  • Specification: 8 scope items for the title. The bill has positions for 6 of them.
  • The two missing items: insulation, 420.00 m² at €18.30 per m², and a fire door set, 3 at €890.00 each. The title total before the check is €96,500.
Step 1 of 3

How many are missing

Scope items minus items with a position. How many are missing?

8 − 6 = 2 items to add.

Step 2 of 3

Value of the two positions

Each is quantity times rate. What do the two add together?

420.00 m² × €18.30 plus 3 × €890.00 = €10,356.

Step 3 of 3

Title after

What is the title total after the two positions?

€96,500 + €10,356 = €106,856.

In short. Check completeness from the specification to the bill, then price what is missing from the measured quantity and the list rate.

Check yourself

Question 1 of 3

The AI report finds no omissions. What does that prove?

  • The report never saw the specification, so it could not test completeness.

  • Comparing a bill with itself can find contradictions, not absences.

  • Rates and quantities are not tested either.

  • The client's wants are written in the specification, which the report did not read.

Question 2 of 3

Where does the quantity of a new position come from?

  • Not auditable; the client cannot check it.

  • The schedule is the agreed record of what was measured, and the figure can be traced.

  • It has no measurement to base one on.

  • That is a copy, not a measurement.

Question 3 of 3

A scope item has quantity 12 at a list rate of 345.00 each, and another has 40 m at 28.50 per m. What do the two add to the title?

12 × 345 = 4,140; 40 × 28.50 = 1,140; together 5,280.