OpenConstruction Academy
Sign in / Register
EN

Theory before task 1 · 9 min

Duplicate or look-alike: prove it from the measurement

Flagged duplicates: which of them is really one

Course introduction

After this lecture you can

  1. Say why a text match between two bill positions does not show that the same work is priced twice.
  2. Test a flagged pair on three things: the same work, the same place, the same measured quantity.
  3. Take out only the value that is really double, and keep a reason for each pair you leave alone.
1 / 3

What a duplicate is

A duplicate is one piece of work paid for twice: the same work, in the same place, measured once but entered in two positions. An automatic check finds pairs by similar text and similar numbers, so it flags a duplicate and a look-alike in exactly the same way. A look-alike is two positions that read alike but cover different work: the same wall build-up on two storeys, or the same plaster on the inside and the outside face. Deleting a look-alike removes real work from the price and the bid becomes cheaper than the job.

Example. The cost of a false alarm is not the time spent checking. It is the work you would have deleted.
2 / 3

Three questions for every flagged pair

Same work? Compare the full description: material, thickness, finish, and what the position includes. Same place? A drawing reference, a storey, a grid line or a room name. Same quantity from the same measurement? The measurement schedule lists where each quantity came from; two positions that draw on the same schedule row are double, two that draw on different rows are not. If any one answer is no, the pair is not a duplicate. If you are unsure, ask who wrote the positions before you change anything.

Example. A Zulage, an addition to a position, can look like a repeat of the position it names. It is not: it prices an extra item on top, and it never replaces the base position.
3 / 3

Removing the double, not the whole line

When a pair is a real duplicate you set one position's quantity to zero, so the position and its rate stay on file but contribute nothing to the sum. The value taken out is the quantity times the rate of the removed position, not the value of both. Then re-read the section total: it must fall by exactly that amount. A report of 'findings' counts how many held; the money is a separate figure and the one the tender depends on.

Example. Keep the count and the value apart in your report: 'three of five findings held, 41,300 taken out'.

Take out what is really double

Different numbers from your task.

Not to scale
The problem
  • Pair 1: two positions for the same render, same grid line, both taken from the same row of the measurement schedule: 86.40 m², rate €63.50. The second one is the repeat.
  • Pair 2: render to the inside face and to the outside face of the same wall, 132.00 m² each, rate €48.00. They come from different rows of the schedule.
  • Section total before the check: €412,000.
Step 1 of 3

Value of the real duplicate

Only one position of pair 1 is removed. What is the value taken out?

86.40 m² × €63.50 = €5,486.

Step 2 of 3

Pair 2

Pair 2 is two faces of one wall, from different schedule rows. How much do you take out?

Nothing: inside and outside are separate work.

Step 3 of 3

Section after the check

What is the section total now?

€412,000 − €5,486 = €406,514.

In short. A duplicate is the same work, in the same place, from the same measurement. Take out only the repeat, and keep the reason for the rest.

Check yourself

Question 1 of 3

The check flags two positions with identical text and identical unit price. What decides whether they are a duplicate?

  • Text is how the tool found the pair. It is not proof.

  • A duplicate is one piece of work entered twice. The schedule shows where each quantity came from.

  • Round totals say nothing about duplication.

  • Confidence is a property of the match, not of the fact.

Question 2 of 3

A Zulage position follows a main position and mentions the same material. The tool flags them. What is the right reading?

  • A Zulage adds an extra to the position it names; removing it removes priced work.

  • Both are paid, each for different work.

  • The base position carries the main work; the Zulage depends on it.

  • Merging hides the structure of the bill and breaks the link between the two.

Question 3 of 3

Two positions are a true duplicate: 140 m² at 22.50 per m². You set one of them to quantity zero. By how much does the section total fall?

140 × 22.50 = 3,150.