OpenConstruction Academy
Sign in / Register
EN

Theory before task 4 · 9 min

Priced but not in the sum

Priced but not in the sum: Bedarf and Alternativ

After this lecture you can

  1. Say what a Bedarfsposition and an Alternativposition are and why they are priced but not counted.
  2. Apply the firm's convention: keep the rate, set the quantity to zero.
  3. Work out a title when the client chooses the alternative.
1 / 3

Two kinds of position outside the sum

A Bedarfsposition (Eventualposition) is work that may be needed, for example extra excavation if the ground turns out worse. It is priced now so that the price is fixed, but it is paid only if it is used. An Alternativposition offers a different way of doing the same work, for example another wall build-up. The client chooses one or the other, and until the client chooses, only the base option counts. The price must be there and must not be in the bill sum, because the bill sum is what the client will be asked to commit to.

Example. A position may be in the bill without being in the sum. The sum is the commitment; the bill is the offer.
2 / 3

How the ERP holds it

The ERP has no flag for 'priced but not in the sum'. The firm's convention is that such a position keeps its unit rate and carries quantity zero. The sum then goes out as the sum of the committed work, and the rate stays on file for the day the client asks. A position with a real quantity and an optional status would be added to the sum by every report, and the bid would overstate the commitment.

Example. Check the area of the base position against the drawings too: if it is the part replaced by the alternative, it is the quantity of the base that counts.
3 / 3

If the client chooses the alternative

The alternative then replaces the base position it was written for, and it takes the quantity of what it replaces: the same area. The base goes to zero, the alternative takes the quantity and its own rate. The title changes by the difference of the two rates times that area. Report the title both ways: with the base and with the alternative, so the client sees what the choice costs.

Example. The choice is the client's, so your report states both outcomes and does not make the decision.
Title with the base wall
€56,000
Title with the alternative wall
€61,600

Zero the optional lines, then switch

Different numbers from your task.

Not to scale
The problem
  • Base position: 210.00 m² at €84.00 per m². Alternative for the same area: €96.50 per m². Bedarf position: 35 at €42.00. Other lines of the title: €15,800.
Step 1 of 3

Title with the base

Base position and the other lines; the Bedarf position is set to zero. What is the title?

210.00 m² × €84.00 + €15,800 = €33,440.

Step 2 of 3

Title with the alternative

The alternative replaces the base on the same area. What is the title?

210.00 m² × €96.50 + €15,800 = €36,065.

Step 3 of 3

What the Bedarf line wrongly added

If left at quantity, by how much would it have overstated the sum?

35 × €42.00 = €1,470.

In short. Priced is not the same as counted. Keep the rate, set the quantity to zero, and show the title both ways.

Check yourself

Question 1 of 3

A Bedarfsposition is priced with a real quantity in the bill. What goes wrong?

  • Reports add every position with a quantity, so the sum includes work that may never happen.

  • The client would be asked to commit to it.

  • The rate stays, but the sum is wrong.

  • It accepts it silently, which is why a convention is needed.

Question 2 of 3

The client has not chosen an Alternativposition. How is it held in the bill?

  • Then the price for it is lost and the client cannot choose later.

  • The rate is on file and the sum does not carry it.

  • Words in a letter do not change the sum in the bill.

  • The alternative has its own rate; borrowing the base's hides the difference.

Question 3 of 3

Base: 75 m² at 52.00; alternative: 75 m² at 58.50. By how much does the title rise if the client chooses the alternative?

(58.50 − 52.00) × 75 = 487.50.