OpenConstruction Academy
Sign in / Register
EN

Theory before task 5 · 9 min

What the audit was worth

Sign off the bill and the report

After this lecture you can

  1. Test a bill's direct cost against the firm's range per m² of floor area, and say what that test shows.
  2. Count the report's findings two ways: how many held and how many corrections it never named.
  3. Write a sign-off that says what was verified and what was not.
1 / 3

The range test

Divide the direct cost by the gross floor area, a measure taken from the design (here DIN 277). Compare with the range the firm has seen on similar projects. If the figure is inside the range, no big section is missing and no decimal point has slipped. If it is outside, something large is wrong or the project is unusual: go and find out which. The test is blunt. Two errors that cancel each other pass it, and a ten per cent error in a sound-looking figure passes too.

Example. A figure inside the range is not an approval. It is the absence of one particular alarm.
2 / 3

Two ways to count the report

Precision: of the findings the report raised, how many held? A report with many false alarms costs checking time and, worse, tempts people to stop checking. Coverage: of the corrections the bill needed, how many did the report name? Every position you changed that no finding mentions is something the report missed. Both numbers matter. A report that is right every time it speaks but speaks rarely is safe and not much use. One that speaks a lot and is often wrong is a burden.

Example. Count by finding number, and count the corrections of your own separately. Do not net them.
3 / 3

The sign-off

A sign-off lists what you checked and how: each finding against the measurement schedule, completeness against the specification, quantities against the preamble, the sum against the range. It then lists what you did not check: rates beyond the sample, the drawings themselves. The figure you sign is the direct cost after your corrections. If someone later finds an error in the part you did not check, the note shows where your check ended.

Example. The report is a tool. The signature is yours.

Read the range and count both ways

Different numbers from your task.

Not to scale
The problem
  • Direct cost €1,120,000, gross floor area 2,300.00 m². Range of the firm: €460.00 to €560.00 per m².
  • The report raised 7 findings; 4 held. You changed 3 positions that no finding named.
Step 1 of 3

Direct cost per m²

Direct cost divided by floor area. What is the figure?

€1,120,000 ÷ 2,300.00 m² = €486.96 per m²: inside €460.00 to €560.00.

Step 2 of 3

Findings that did not hold

How many of the report's findings were false?

7 − 4 = 3 false.

Step 3 of 3

Corrections beyond the report

How many corrections did the report not name, and how many did the bill need in total?

4 + 3 = 7 needed; the report named 4 of them.

In short. The range test finds large errors only. Count the findings that held, and the corrections the report never named.

Check yourself

Question 1 of 3

The direct cost per m² is inside the firm's range. What may you conclude?

  • Offsetting errors and small ones pass the range test.

  • That is the alarm the test raises.

  • Rates cannot be seen from a total.

  • The report's findings are tested one by one against the schedule.

Question 2 of 3

The report raised five findings; two held. What is the right reading?

  • It still found two real errors and a check must be done anyway.

  • Both numbers say what the report was worth.

  • False alarms cost time and risk real deletions.

  • The false ones and the missed ones are part of the answer.

Question 3 of 3

A report raised 9 findings and 6 held. You changed 5 positions that no finding named. How many corrections did the bill need in total?

6 held plus 5 of your own = 11.