OpenConstruction Academy
Sign in / Register
EN

Theory before task 4 · 8 min

Closing topics on evidence

Close only what the re-run proves

After this lecture you can

  1. Respond to and close an RFI once its answer is in.
  2. Read a re-run against the clash rules.
  3. Close, keep or reopen each topic on the re-run, not the comment.
1 / 4

Close the RFI when the question is settled

An RFI is answered when the designer replies, and closed when the answer is enough to build from, usually with a revised drawing. Record the answer in the RFI, then close it. Whatever it cost stays on the record for the compensation event.

Example. Answer recorded, drawing issued, RFI closed.
2 / 4

The rules of the re-run

A clash test has rules. On this job, structure against services reports a hard clash when one passes more than 10 mm into the other, and a clearance clash when the gap is over 0 and up to 50 mm. A limit 'up to and including' means a gap exactly on the limit is still reported.

Example. A duct moved 20 mm is better, and still a clash.
Gap before, mm
£25
Gap after the reroute, mm
£45
Clearance asked for, mm
£50
3 / 4

Resolved, Closed, Reopened

In BCF the designer who made a change marks the topic Resolved; the coordinator who checks it on the re-run closes it, or reopens it if the clash is still there. A topic still in progress stays open with its due date.

Example. Resolved means 'I think it is fixed'; Closed means 'the model shows it is'.
Common mistake

Closing on the designer's word

A comment that says the pipe was lowered sounds final, and closing it saves a re-run. But a 20 mm move on a 30 mm gap lands exactly on a 50 mm limit, and the rule still reports it. Close on the re-run, never on the comment.

Example. The clash found on site costs a pipe taken down and hung again.

A duct below a roof beam

Same job, a topic from the roof: a duct under beam B-19.

Not to scale
The problem
  • Gap below the beam on the first run: 25 mm.
  • The designer lowers the duct 20 mm and marks the topic Resolved.
  • The rule reports a gap up to and including 50 mm.
Step 1 of 2

New gap

What is the gap after the move, in mm?

25 + 20 = 45 mm, still inside the rule: reopen.

Step 2 of 2

Further move

What is the smallest further whole-mm drop that clears the rule?

50 − 45 + 1 = 6 mm.

In short. Close what the re-run shows clear; reopen what it still reports, with the reason.

Check yourself

Question 1 of 2

A topic is marked Resolved; the re-run still reports it. What status do you set?

  • Right.

  • The re-run says it is not fixed.

  • Then the designer thinks it is done.

  • Say why it came back.

Question 2 of 2

A pipe sat 35 mm below a beam and was lowered 10 mm. The rule reports gaps up to and including 50 mm. What is the new gap in mm?

35 + 10 = 45 mm: still reported.

Read the source

Free official texts. The lecture cites clause numbers and puts the rules in its own words.