OpenConstruction Academy
Sign in / Register
EN

Theory before task 3 · 9 min

Clash topics: who fixes what, by when

Five clash topics: due dates from the programme

After this lecture you can

  1. Read a clash run as topics with an owner and a fix.
  2. Date each topic from the activity that builds its fix.
  3. Tell a fix to the Client's structure from a reroute in your own design.
1 / 4

From clashes to topics

A clash run finds every place one model hits another; most of them repeat the same problem. The coordinator groups them into topics, one per zone and system, and shares them as BCF: an open format whose topics carry a title, a status, a priority, a due date and comments. Each topic has one fix and one owner.

Example. Fourteen raw clashes on this job become five topics.
2 / 4

Due before it is built

A fix is due before the work that builds it starts: an opening in a slab before that slab's formwork, an opening in a beam before the beam is cast, a reroute before the services go up. Read the start date off the programme and take the last working day before it.

Example. Count in working days, then turn the day number back into a date.
Working day the activity starts92
Topic due, working day91
3 / 4

Whose design

If the fix changes the concrete, the structural engineer has to design it, and on this job that engineer works for the Client: the question goes through the Project Manager. If the fix moves a duct or a pipe, it is your M&E design, and your own team answers it. High priority goes to fixes that change concrete, because concrete cannot be changed afterwards.

Example. A sleeve is the engineer's; a lowered pipe is yours.
Common mistake

Coring a column for a duct

A duct drawn through a column looks like a question for the engineer. It is not: a column is not cut for services. The duct is rerouted, and the topic belongs to the M&E designer, due before first fix.

Example. Send it to the engineer and you lose weeks for an answer that is always no.

A ground-floor drain under the slab

Same job, an earlier topic: a drain that clashed with a pad foundation.

Not to scale
The problem
  • The foundations start on working day 15.
  • The fix is a lowered drain, your own design.
  • Your drainage designer needs 3 working days to revise the run.
Step 1 of 2

Due

On which working day is the topic due?

15 − 1 = 14.

Step 2 of 2

Start the redesign

By which working day must the redesign start?

14 − 3 = 11.

In short. The work that builds the fix sets the due date; the owner of the design answers.

Check yourself

Question 1 of 2

A pipe runs 30 mm below a beam; the matrix asks for 50 mm. Who fixes it?

  • Right.

  • The beam is not moved for a pipe.

  • Then it is a clash found in the air.

  • The matrix asks for 50.

Question 2 of 2

An activity starts on working day 40. On which working day is a topic for it due?

The last working day before day 40 is day 39.

Read the source

Free official texts. The lecture cites clause numbers and puts the rules in its own words.