OpenConstruction Academy
Sign in / Register
EN

Theory before task 2 · 8 min

The Project Manager's own assessment

The Project Manager's own assessment of CE-05

After this lecture you can

  1. Know when the Project Manager assesses an event itself (clause 64).
  2. Rebuild a quotation without the cost the event did not cause.
  3. Separate the implemented value from the balance in dispute.
1 / 3

When the Project Manager assesses

Under clause 64.1 the Project Manager makes its own assessment when, among other cases, it decides the Contractor has not assessed the event correctly. It notifies the assessment, and the event is implemented at that value (65.1). The Contractor does not have to agree for the money to move.

Example. The Project Manager accepts most of a quotation and removes one cost it says the event did not cause.
2 / 3

Defined Cost plus Fee, in two rates

An event is priced as its effect on Defined Cost plus the Fee (63.1). The Fee has two percentages in the Contract Data: one on the Contractor's own cost, a lower one on subcontracted cost. Take a cost out and its own Fee goes with it.

Own cost£3,200.00
Fee 10 % on own£320.00
Subcontracted cost£1,840.00
Fee 5 % on subcontracted£92.00
Common mistake

One Fee on everything

Putting the higher Fee on subcontracted cost overstates the event a little, every time. Across a final account with many events the small overstatements add up to a figure the Project Manager will strike out line by line.

Example. Check the Fee line of every quotation against the two Contract Data percentages before it leaves the office.

CE-02, on the same job

The old footing under SF1. The Contractor quoted one and a half excavator days; the Project Manager accepted one.

Not to scale
The problem
  • Quotation £2,060.53, Fee 10 % on own cost.
  • Excavator with driver, own plant, £420.00 per day.
  • The Project Manager removes half a day: the excavator was on site for the Contractor's own work anyway.
Step 1 of 3

Cost removed

How much Defined Cost does the Project Manager remove?

£420.00 × 0.5 = £210.00.

Step 2 of 3

With its Fee

How much comes off the quotation, Fee included?

£210.00 × 1.10 = £231.00.

£2,0611−£2312?3
  • 1 Quotation
  • 2 Half day with Fee
  • 3 Assessed
£2,0611−£2312£1,8303
  • 1 Quotation
  • 2 Half day with Fee
  • 3 Assessed
Step 3 of 3

The assessed value

What value is CE-02 implemented at?

£2,060.53 − £231.00 = £1,829.53. The Contractor accepted it; had it not, £231.00 would have been the balance in dispute.

In short. Rebuild the quotation line by line, remove what the event did not cause together with its Fee, and keep the difference as the disputed balance.

Check yourself

Question 1 of 2

The Contractor disagrees with the Project Manager's assessment. Is the event implemented?

  • Right (65.1). The Contractor can still refer the difference to adjudication.

  • Agreement is not needed for an assessment to be implemented.

Question 2 of 2

The Project Manager removes £600 of subcontracted cost from a quotation. Fee on subcontracted cost is 5 %. How much is in dispute?

£600 × 1.05 = £630.

Read the source

Free official texts. The lecture cites clause numbers and puts the rules in its own words.