OpenConstruction Academy
Sign in / Register
EN

Theory before task 5 · 7 min

Re-inspection, the repeat-test cost and closing an NCR

Re-inspect, pay for the repeat test, close NCR-001

After this lecture you can

  1. Say when an NCR may be closed and what must be on record first.
  2. Separate the Client's cost of a repeat inspection from the Contractor's own.
  3. Calculate what the Contractor pays the Client after a repeat inspection.
1 / 3

Closing an NCR

An NCR closes when three things are on record: the correction was made, a re-inspection shows it works, and the preventive action is in place for the next time. In the ERP the NCR moves to Verification after the repair and to Closed after the re-inspection passes. Closing it without the preventive action leaves the roof slab open to the same failure.

Example. The next pour, the roof slab, is the test of whether the NCR really closed.
Identifiedraised from INS-001
Under reviewsurvey and grade
Corrective actioncause, remedy, cost
Verificationre-inspection passed
Closedpreventive action in the next ITP
2 / 3

Who pays for the repeat

Under NEC4 (clause 41.6) when a test or inspection is repeated after a Defect is found, the Project Manager assesses the Client's cost of repeating it and the Contractor pays that amount. The Client's cost is its own people's time and anyone it hires. The Contractor's own cost of repeating stays with the Contractor and goes on its NCR, not to the Client.

Example. Two blue parts are paid across; the red part stays on your NCR.
£240.00£500.00£400.00
  • Supervisor's time (Client) £240.00
  • Client's test house (Client) £500.00
  • Your own specialist (yours) £400.00
Common mistake

Paying across the Contractor's own costs

When the Project Manager's assessment arrives, it is tempting to agree a round sum that includes everything on the visit. Check each item: whose cost was it? Only the Client's cost of repeating is payable. Your own specialist's fee is real, and it belongs on your NCR, not in the payment.

Example. Ask for the assessment item by item, with hours and rates, before you agree it.

The sum paid to the Client

Different numbers from your task.

Not to scale
The problem
  • Supervisor 3 h at £80.00. Client's test house £500.00. Your own specialist £400.00.
Step 1 of 2

Supervisor

Cost of the Supervisor's time?

3 × £80.00 = £240.00.

Step 2 of 2

Paid to the Client

What does the Contractor pay the Client?

£240.00 + £500.00 = £740.00. Your £400.00 stays on your NCR.

In short. Client's costs are paid across; your own stay with you.

Check yourself

Question 1 of 3

The repair is done but not yet re-inspected. May NCR-001 be closed?

  • Done is not verified.

  • Right.

  • Cost is not evidence that the fix works.

Question 2 of 3

Which cost does the Contractor pay the Client after a repeat inspection?

  • Right: clause 41.6.

  • The Contractor's own costs are not paid across.

  • Not after a Defect was found.

Question 3 of 3

Supervisor 5 h at 70.00; Client's test house 450.00; your specialist 300.00. What does the Contractor pay the Client?

350.00 + 450.00 = 800.00.

Read the source

Free official texts. The lecture cites clause numbers and puts the rules in its own words.