OpenConstruction Academy
Sign in / Register
EN

Theory before task 4 · 8 min

The cost of rework, and who pays it

The cost of putting it right

After this lecture you can

  1. List the parts of the cost of a Defect, direct and time-related.
  2. Price standing time from the delay to the critical path.
  3. Say why under NEC4 Option B none of it is paid by the Client.
1 / 3

Five parts of a Defect's cost

The repair crew is the visible part. Before it come the survey and the engineer's time; around it come access, and behind it comes time: every working day the critical path waits, the site's time-related overheads (supervision, welfare, cabins, plant on hire) keep running. A full NCR cost adds all five.

Example. In this example the standing time costs more than the repair. That is common when the Defect sits on the critical path.
+£900.001+£540.002+£1,800.003+£200.004+£2,000.005£5,440.006
  • 1 Survey
  • 2 Engineer
  • 3 Repair
  • 4 Access
  • 5 Standing time
  • 6 Total
2 / 3

Who pays under Option B

Under NEC4 Option B the Contractor is paid the Prices for the work it does. A Defect is work not in accordance with the Scope (clause 11.2(6)), and the Contractor corrects it (section 4 of the contract). Correcting it earns nothing more and is not a compensation event, so the whole cost stays with the Contractor. The NCR is where that cost is recorded, so the firm sees what quality failures cost it.

Example. The exception is a search the Supervisor instructs that finds no Defect: that is a compensation event (clause 60.1(10)).
£5,440.00
  • Paid by the Client £0.00
  • Borne by the Contractor £5,440.00
Common mistake

Pricing only the repair

An NCR priced at the repair crew's invoice looks cheap, and the lesson is lost. Add the survey, the engineer, the access and the standing time. Price the delay in working days, the same days you counted for the programme.

Example. If the delay was counted in working days, the overheads are priced per working day, not per calendar day.

Pricing an NCR

Different numbers from your task.

Not to scale
The problem
  • Survey £900.00. Engineer 6 h at £90.00. Repair 30.00 m² at £60.00 per m². One tower for a week £200.00. Delay 4 working days at £500.00 a day.
Step 1 of 4

Engineer

Engineer's cost?

6 × £90.00 = £540.00.

Step 2 of 4

Repair

Repair cost?

30.00 m² × £60.00 = £1,800.00.

Step 3 of 4

Standing time

Cost of the delay?

4 × £500.00 = £2,000.00.

Step 4 of 4

Total

Cost of the NCR?

£900.00 + £540.00 + £1,800.00 + £200.00 + £2,000.00 = £5,440.00.

In short. Survey, engineer, repair, access and time: the full price of a skipped check.

Check yourself

Question 1 of 3

Can the Contractor include the NCR cost in its next application under Option B?

  • Correcting a Defect is not a compensation event.

  • Right.

  • The survey found a Defect, so it stays with the Contractor too.

Question 2 of 3

The repair takes two days but the critical path waits five working days. How many days of overheads go on the NCR?

  • The site waits for the critical path, not for the repair crew.

  • Right.

  • The Prices cover the planned time, not the extra days.

Question 3 of 3

Survey 1,000.00; repair 40 m² at 50.00; delay 3 working days at 600.00 a day. What is the NCR cost?

1,000.00 + 2,000.00 + 1,800.00 = 4,800.00.

Read the source

Free official texts. The lecture cites clause numbers and puts the rules in its own words.