OpenConstruction Academy
Sign in / Register
EN

Theory before task 3 · 8 min

Logic: every link needs a construction reason

Invented links: the logic the AI made up

After this lecture you can

  1. Tell a link the work needs from a link the draft invented.
  2. Run a forward pass on a small network.
  3. Find what invented links cost in duration and float.
1 / 4

What a link says

A finish-to-start link says one activity cannot start until another has finished. It is true only for a reason: the wall must exist before it is rendered, the roof must be on before the floor finish, the same crew cannot be in two places. A link without a reason delays the second activity for nothing.

PhysicalWalls before render
ProtectionRoof before floor finishes
ResourceOne crew, one place at a time
NoneDelete the link
2 / 4

Where invented links come from

A tool that orders activities by their number in a list, or links everything that ends before the next thing begins, produces a chain. Real work runs in parallel: services go in while the roof is built, external works start once the foundations are done. Check every link against the design's construction sequence.

Example. Windows after floor tiling is a chain from the list order, not from the building.
3 / 4

Forward pass

Each activity starts when the last of its predecessors finishes. Walk the network from the start, adding durations along each path; where paths meet, take the later. The longest path from start to end is the programme's duration.

A then B
8 (2 + 6)
A then D
9 (2 + 7)
4 / 4

Float

Total float is how far an activity can slip without moving the finish: the length of the longest path less the longest path through that activity. An invented link can turn an activity with weeks of float into a critical one, and the whole programme follows it.

Example. External works with plenty of float suddenly critical is a sign of a link nobody needed.

Remove an invented link

A five-activity network, durations in working days. Type your answer first.

Not to scale
The problem
  • A 2, B 6, C 5, D 7, E 2.
  • Design sequence: B and D after A; C after B; E after C and D.
  • The draft also has D after B.
A-B-C-E
15
A-B-D-E
?
A-B-C-E
15
A-B-D-E
17
Step 1 of 3

Draft duration

How long is the draft programme, with D after B?

2 + 6 + 7 + 2 = 17 working days.

A-B-C-E
?
A-D-E
11
A-B-C-E
15
A-D-E
11
Step 2 of 3

Corrected duration

How long is it with only the design links?

A-B-C-E is 15; A-D-E is 11. The longest is 15. The invented link added 17 − 15 = 2 days.

Through D
?
Critical path
15
Through D
15 (11 + 4)
Critical path
15
Step 3 of 3

Float of D

What is the total float of D in the corrected programme?

15 − 11 = 4 days. In the draft D was critical, with none.

In short. Delete links that have no construction reason, re-run the forward pass, and read what they had added in duration and taken in float.

Check yourself

Question 1 of 2

The draft links 'external paving' after 'internal doors'. Is that a construction reason?

  • Nothing physical ties paving outside to doors inside.

  • Paving can follow the foundations.

Question 2 of 2

Paths through a network take 23, 19 and 26 working days. How long is the programme?

The longest path: 26 working days.