OpenConstruction Academy
Sign in / Register
EN

Theory before task 2 · 10 min

A real rate for the wrong item

Matching: a real rate for the wrong item

After this lecture you can

  1. Explain why a text match between a quotation and a bill line does not prove that the two describe the same work.
  2. Check four things on every matched rate: unit, scope, delivered or installed, and specification.
  3. Convert a rate to the unit of the bill before you multiply, and find the largest error by its value.
1 / 3

Same words, different work

A language model matches by wording. The bill says 'sandwich panel' and a quotation says 'sandwich panel', so the quotation is picked. But a bill line prices a finished piece of work in place, while a quotation often prices only what the supplier sells. The match is therefore only a candidate. You confirm it by comparing the two descriptions line by line, as you would compare two contracts. The rate is real; the question is whether it is the rate of this item.

Example. A cheap rate that is real and wrong is more dangerous than an invented one, because it survives a casual check.
2 / 3

Four mismatches that appear again and again

Unit: the quotation is per door, the bill counts in m², or the reverse. Scope: ex-works means the supplier's yard, so transport, craneage and fixing are still missing; the bill needs the item erected in place. Composition: the quote is for the sheet alone, the bill line is a composite build-up with fixings, flashings and insulation. Specification: 100 mm panel is not 60 mm panel, and a fire rating or a coating can change the price by a third. Each mismatch has a repair: convert the unit, add the missing cost from the resource rates, take the right composite row from the library, or ask the supplier for the right size.

Example. In the figure the ex-works rate is two thirds of the rate for the item in place. Priced as quoted, every square metre would be short.
€34€11.50
  • Supplied, ex-works €34
  • Delivery and craneage €3.50
  • Fixing labour and fixings €11.50
3 / 3

Order of checking and the largest error

Check the unit first, because a unit error is the biggest in value and the easiest to miss: a rate per door applied to an area, or the reverse, is wrong by the factor between the two units. Then scope, then specification. When the report asks for the largest single error, compare the value of each correction, not its percentage. A 5 % error on a 2 million line is worth more than a 40 % error on a 20 thousand line. Rank by the signed value change, and say which line it is and why it was wrong.

Example. Write the reason beside every correction in one sentence. If you cannot say what was wrong with the match, you have not understood the line yet.

Convert, complete, then compare lines

Different numbers from your task.

Not to scale
The problem
  • Roof liner panel: quotation €34.00 per m² ex-works. Carriage and craneage add €3.50 per m²; fixing labour and fixings add €11.50 per m². Quantity 640.00 m².
  • Doors: 18 doors, each 1.90 m². The assistant priced the line at a library rate of €690.00 per door but entered the quantity as area.
Step 1 of 3

Rate in place

Ex-works plus delivery plus fixing. What is the rate per m² for the panel in place?

€34.00 + €3.50 + €11.50 = €49.00 per m².

Step 2 of 3

Error on the panel line

The assistant priced the line at the ex-works rate. By how much was the line too low?

640.00 m² × (€49.00 − €34.00) = €9,600.

Step 3 of 3

The door line

The rate is per door, so the bill needs a count. What is the correct door line total?

18 doors × €690.00 = €12,420. Multiplying the rate by an area would misstate the line by the factor between the units.

In short. Convert the unit and complete the scope before you multiply. A real rate for another item is still the wrong rate.

Check yourself

Question 1 of 3

A quotation is written per m² and the bill line is per door. What is the correct first move?

  • The units differ, so the product is meaningless: the line would be out by the area of one door.

  • Make the unit of the rate the unit of the quantity before you multiply.

  • An average of two numbers in different units is not a rate for anything.

  • It will explain the match fluently. That is not a check; you must compare the two descriptions.

Question 2 of 3

A supplier quote says 'ex-works'. The bill line is for the item installed. What is missing from the quote?

  • A quote prices the supplier's scope only.

  • Those belong in the markup stack, not in a net rate. Do not load them in.

  • Ex-works ends at the supplier's gate. The rest of the in-place cost comes from resource rates.

  • The quantity is measured from the drawings. It does not change because of the delivery term.

Question 3 of 3

A bill line has 520 m² of cladding. The assistant used the sheet-only quote of 28.00 per m² although the composite item in the library reads 41.50 per m². By how much is the line too low?

(41.50 − 28.00) = 13.50 per m²; 520 × 13.50 = 7,020.