OpenConstruction Academy
Sign in / Register
EN

Theory before task 1 · 9 min

A cited source is a claim, not evidence

Provenance first: which of the assistant's rates has a source at all

Course introduction

After this lecture you can

  1. Say what a rate must prove before you accept it: that it exists, that it is current and that it fits the item.
  2. Test a cited library code in three steps and correct the line when any step fails.
  3. Measure what a failed source costs the bill, per line and in total.
1 / 3

Why a citation proves nothing yet

An assistant that writes a price also writes a source next to it, and the source looks just as confident as the price. A language model produces text that resembles a code, so a code can be well formed and still point to nothing, to an old edition, or to a different item. Professional estimators treat every cited rate as a claim that somebody has to check. The word for this is provenance: where a figure came from, and whether you can walk back to it. A rate without provenance is a guess, however sensible it looks.

Example. Two rates for the same item can both be real: one from this year's library, one from an edition that was replaced last year. Only one of them is allowed in this tender.
2 / 3

Three tests, in this order

1. Exists: the code is a row in the library you are allowed to use. 2. Current: it is the edition in force for this tender, not one marked superseded. 3. Fits: the row describes the same work in the same unit, so a rate per m² is not used for a quantity in metres. Stop at the first test that fails, because a later test cannot rescue an earlier one. A line that passes all three keeps its rate. A line that fails is re-priced from the current library, or from a quotation or a build-up when the library has no row.

3 / 3

Count the money, not only the lines

How many lines failed is a useful number for the report. How much the bill was wrong by is the number the tender depends on. For each failed line the correction is the quantity times the difference between the right rate and the cited one, and the signs matter: a stale rate can be too high or too low. Add the corrections with their signs. A bill can look the same size after a check and still hold large errors that cancel each other.

Example. The net change is smaller than the largest single error. Report both: the net, and the gross of the corrections.
Line A corrected upwards€18,900
Line B corrected downwards−€6,200
Line C corrected upwards€3,100
Net change to the bill€15,800

Check one line and total the damage

Different numbers from your task. Type the answer first; a wrong guess costs nothing.

Not to scale
The problem
  • Masonry wall item, quantity 430.00 m². The assistant cited a code whose row exists but belongs to the superseded edition, rate €41.20. The current edition row for the same item reads €44.80.
  • The whole section total in the draft is €1,800,000.
Step 1 of 3

Rate difference

Current rate minus the cited rate, per m². What is the difference?

€44.80 − €41.20 = €3.60 per m².

Step 2 of 3

Correction on the line

Quantity times the rate difference. By how much does the line change?

430.00 m² × €3.60 = €1,548. The line was too low by this amount.

Step 3 of 3

Share of the section

What share of the section total does this one correction represent, in per cent?

€1,548 ÷ €1,800,000 = 0.086%. One stale line is small, which is why checking all lines matters: the errors add up.

In short. A rate is accepted for its source, not for its look. Check that it exists, that it is current and that it fits, then correct by quantity times the difference.

Check yourself

Question 1 of 3

A cited code exists in the rate library. What still has to be checked before you accept the rate?

  • Existing is only the first test. The row can be superseded or describe another item.

  • That is the second and third test. The assistant's confidence tells you nothing about either.

  • Comparing with a feeling is not provenance. A rate is accepted because of its source, not because of its size.

  • Repeating a citation does not make it more true; a model can repeat a wrong code as easily as a right one.

Question 2 of 3

The old and the current edition give the same rate for a line. The assistant cited the old one. What do you do?

  • This tender must be priced from the current edition. Fix the reference so the audit trail is correct, even if the money is the same.

  • The figure is unchanged but the source is now one you may use. Next year's edition may differ and the file must show why.

  • The work is still in the scope. Removing the line removes the work from the price.

  • Nothing is excluded. A reference problem is not a scope decision.

Question 3 of 3

A line has quantity 250 m². The assistant cited a rate of 19.50 per m² from a superseded row; the current row reads 23.10 per m². By how much does the bill change after the correction?

(23.10 − 19.50) = 3.60 per m²; 250 × 3.60 = 900.