OpenConstruction Academy
Sign in / Register
EN

Theory before task 2 · 9 min

From a failed inspection to a graded NCR

NCR-001 and the cover survey

After this lecture you can

  1. Raise an NCR from a failed inspection and say what it must record.
  2. Grade an NCR on evidence using a severity guide.
  3. Measure the area that fails a specification limit, reading 'not less than' correctly.
1 / 3

Nominal cover and the acceptable limit

Cover is the concrete between a bar and the face of the slab. It protects the steel from corrosion and fire. The designer specifies a nominal cover and allows for the fact that steel moves a little during the pour: Eurocode 2 (BS EN 1992-1-1, 4.4.1.3) calls this the allowance for deviation, 10 mm in the UK. On this job a reading is acceptable if it is not less than the nominal less 10 mm.

Example. Nominal is the target the fixers aim at; the limit is what the survey is judged against.
Nominal cover (example)35
Less the execution tolerance10
Acceptable limit, not less than25
2 / 3

Grade on the evidence

An NCR records what is wrong, where, how it was found, its severity, the cause, the correction and its cost. The ERP proposes a severity when it raises the NCR from a failed inspection; the quality plan decides it. Critical means unsafe or to be broken out; major means repaired or accepted by the designer; minor means cosmetic. Grade after the survey, not before.

Example. Lowest reading per bay, in mm, against a 25 mm limit: bays 2 and 4 fail, bay 3 passes on the limit.
Bay 1
28
Bay 2
22
Bay 3
25
Bay 4
19
Common mistake

Judging against the nominal

Measured against the nominal, almost every slab fails somewhere, and the NCR grows to cover bays that meet the specification. The specification already allows for the tolerance. Judge each reading against the acceptable limit, and read the words: 'not less than' means a reading on the limit passes.

Example. A larger NCR is not a safer NCR. It sends repair money to concrete that complies.

The area below the limit

Different numbers from your task.

Not to scale
The problem
  • Limit 25 mm. Bay 1: 30.00 m², 28 mm. Bay 2: 26.00 m², 22 mm. Bay 3: 24.00 m², 25 mm. Bay 4: 20.00 m², 19 mm.
Step 1 of 2

Bays that fail

How many bays read less than 25 mm?

Bays 2 and 4: 2 bays.

Step 2 of 2

Area

What area is below the limit?

26.00 m² + 20.00 m² = 46.00 m².

In short. Compare with the limit, add the failing bays only.

Check yourself

Question 1 of 3

The survey shows low cover in two bays, repairable without breaking anything out. Which severity fits the guide?

  • Critical is for unsafe work or work that must come out.

  • Right: repaired or accepted by the designer.

  • Low cover affects durability and fire resistance; it is not cosmetic.

Question 2 of 3

The limit is 'not less than 20 mm'. A bay reads exactly 20 mm. Does it fail?

  • 'Not less than' includes the limit.

  • Right.

  • The limit already allows for the nominal.

Question 3 of 3

Limit 25 mm. Bay P 40.00 m² reads 24 mm; bay Q 35.00 m² reads 26 mm; bay R 30.00 m² reads 21 mm. What area is below the limit, in m²?

Bays P and R: 40.00 + 30.00 = 70.00 m².

Read the source

Free official texts. The lecture cites clause numbers and puts the rules in its own words.