OpenConstruction Academy
Sign in / Register
EN

Theory before task 3 · 9 min

Award the leveled low, and hold the sub to it

The leveled low, not the machine's rank

After this lecture you can

  1. Rank bids on the same scope, not on their totals as bid.
  2. Award at the leveled price when part of a bid is carried elsewhere.
  3. Know why a sub cannot withdraw a price you relied on.
1 / 4

What a machine ranking compares

An ERP that ranks bids on their totals compares whatever each sub chose to price. If one bid includes a line another trade carries, it looks dearer than it is; if one leaves a line out, it looks cheaper. The ranking is a starting point. The leveled sheet, with every bid on one scope, is what you award from.

Example. Two painting bids where B also priced a line the GC buys elsewhere.
Bid A as bid
$98,400
Bid B as bid
$101,900
Bid B, carried scope out
$101,900
2 / 4

Awarding at the leveled price

When the low bidder priced a line you buy from another trade, award it without that line, at the price of the lines you are buying. The scope sheet already shows that line's price, so nothing is negotiated: the award simply leaves the line out.

Example. On this job the joints are bought once, from the firestopping sub.
3 / 4

Holding the sub to its price

In California a sub's bid that the general contractor reasonably relied on when it priced its own bid cannot be withdrawn before the GC has had a chance to accept it. The leading case is Drennan v. Star Paving Co. (1958), decided on promissory estoppel. The protection runs both ways in practice: the listing law stops the GC shopping the listed sub's price after the bid.

Example. A sub that calls at 4:30 pm with a mistake is held to the number you used at 2:00 pm.
Common mistake

Awarding the first rank

The ERP shows a first rank and a recommended bidder, and the award button is one click away. Awarding from it skips the question the estimator is paid to answer: are these numbers for the same work? Level first, then award.

Example. The machine ranks totals; you rank scope.

Two painting bids

Same bid, the painting package.

Not to scale
The problem
  • Bid A: $98,400, no graffiti coating.
  • Bid B: $101,900, graffiti coating priced at $6,200.
  • The graffiti coating is bought from the specialty coatings sub.
Step 1 of 2

B leveled

What is bid B without the coating?

$101,900 − $6,200 = $95,700.00.

Step 2 of 2

The gap

By how much is B lower than A once leveled?

$98,400 − $95,700.00 = $2,700.00.

In short. Same scope first; the award goes to the leveled low, at its leveled price.

Check yourself

Question 1 of 2

The ERP ranks bid B second, but B priced a line you buy elsewhere. What next?

  • Right.

  • It compared totals as bid.

  • You would buy the line twice.

  • Extra lines are taken out, not punished.

Question 2 of 2

Bid B is 233,700 including a 12,400 line you buy elsewhere. At what amount do you award B?

233,700 − 12,400 = 221,300.

Read the source

Free official texts. The lecture cites clause numbers and puts the rules in its own words.