OpenConstruction Academy
Sign in / Register
EN

Theory before task 2 · 9 min

From a failed inspection to an NCR and its cost

NCR-001: root cause and the cost of rework

After this lecture you can

  1. Raise an NCR and grade it from the evidence.
  2. Find a root cause you can change (ISO 9001 10.2).
  3. Price everything a nonconformity costs, time and the Employer's repeat inspection included (FIDIC 7.5).
1 / 3

Contain, correct, find the cause

ISO 9001 asks for two things when work does not conform. First control it: stop it going further, correct it, and record what was done (8.7). Then find why it happened and act so it does not happen again, and check the action worked (10.2). A nonconformance report (NCR) holds both: what was wrong, its grade, the root cause, the correction and its cost.

Example. Ask why until the answer is a step you can change: missing spacers, no re-order, a notice sent without a pre-check.
2 / 3

Who pays

Under FIDIC 7.5 the Engineer can reject work that is not to the contract, and the contractor makes it good. If the rejection and the repeat test cost the Employer more, the Employer may claim that cost from the contractor under 20.2. Under 7.6 the Engineer can instruct remedial work; if the contractor does not do it, the Employer may have it done and recover the cost.

Example. The first inspection is the Engineer's ordinary work. A second visit caused by the contractor's defect is the contractor's cost.
+$3601+$7202+$3,0003+$2004$4,2805
  • 1 Rework
  • 2 Cancelled concrete
  • 3 Days lost
  • 4 Repeat inspection
  • 5 NCR cost
Common mistake

Pricing only the repair

The repair is what everyone sees, so it is what gets priced. When the delayed work is on the critical path, the site's time-related costs run on every working day it waits, and they are usually the largest part. Count working days, not calendar days.

Example. Two working days of a site that costs 1,500 a day outweigh a 360 repair many times.

Cost of a held pour

Different numbers from your task.

Not to scale
The problem
  • Rework 12 hours at $30; 80 m3 cancelled at $9 a m3.
  • 2 working days lost at $1,500 a day; the Engineer's repeat inspection $200.
Step 1 of 2

Direct cost

Rework and cancelled concrete?

12 × $30 + 80 × $9 = $1,080.

Step 2 of 2

Total

Cost on the NCR?

$1,080 + 2 × $1,500 + $200 = $4,280.

In short. Repair, deliveries stood down, days lost and the Employer's repeat inspection: all on the NCR.

Check yourself

Question 1 of 3

A survey shows low cover in two bays that a repair mortar can restore. The NCR is...

  • Right. Grade by consequence, not by trade or programme.

  • Critical is for unsafe work or work that must come out.

  • It needs rework before work goes on.

Question 2 of 3

Which is a root cause, not a symptom?

  • Right. It is a step you can change.

  • That is what the inspection found, the symptom.

  • That is the outcome.

Question 3 of 3

A repair costs 700 and the pour lost 4 working days at 1,200 a day. NCR cost?

700 + 4 × 1,200 = 5,500.

Read the source

Free official texts. The lecture cites clause numbers and puts the rules in its own words.