OpenConstruction Academy
Sign in / Register
EN

Theory before task 2 · 8 min

The hierarchy of controls and residual risk

The hierarchy of controls and residual risk

After this lecture you can

  1. Name the five levels of the hierarchy in order.
  2. Choose the highest practicable control.
  3. Rescore a hazard after its control.
1 / 3

Five levels

ISO 45001 8.1.2 orders controls: eliminate the hazard; substitute something less hazardous; engineering controls that separate people from it; administrative controls such as rules, permits and training; and personal protective equipment last. Higher controls work without anyone having to remember to do something.

Example. Working on a roof edge: prefabricate the unit at ground level (elimination), or fit edge protection (engineering), rather than issue harnesses.
$1$1$1$1$1
  • PPE $1
  • Administrative $1
  • Engineering $1
  • Substitution $1
  • Elimination $1
2 / 3

What changes after a control

Residual risk is the score with the control in place. Most controls lower the likelihood. Severity falls only when the hazard itself changes: a de-energised cable cannot shock anyone, but a guard rail does not make the drop any lower.

Example. Unsupported trench 4 × 4. With trench boxes: severity 4, likelihood 1, residual 4.
Common mistake

A reminder as a control

Telling people to take care is the weakest administrative step there is. If the score does not change after the 'control', it was not one. Look for something that changes the work, not the warning.

Example. 'Be careful near the edge' leaves the edge as open as it was.

Residual risk of a trench

Different numbers from your task.

Not to scale
The problem
  • Option A: a banksman watches the trench edge, likelihood 3.
  • Option B: trench boxes, likelihood 1. Severity stays 4.
Step 1 of 1

Choose and rescore

Residual score with the higher control?

4 × 1 = 4.

In short. Choose the highest practicable control, then rescore with its values.

Check yourself

Question 1 of 3

Which control is highest in the hierarchy?

  • Right. The hazard is gone.

  • Administrative.

  • PPE is the last line.

Question 2 of 3

A guard rail is fitted. Which value falls?

  • Right. The fall is prevented; its consequence is unchanged.

  • The drop is still there.

  • Only a change of the hazard itself lowers severity.

Question 3 of 3

Severity 5, likelihood 4; edge protection brings likelihood to 1. Residual score?

5 × 1 = 5.

Read the source

Free official texts. The lecture cites clause numbers and puts the rules in its own words.