OpenConstruction Academy
Sign in / Register
EN

Theory before task 3 · 11 min

Valuing a directed change as a variation

Value the slab thickening as a variation

After this lecture you can

  1. Measure only the extra work a direction adds, not the work the bill already pays for.
  2. Choose between a bill rate and an agreed rate for each component.
  3. Add the Annexure margin once, and keep GST out of the variation.
1 / 3

Value the difference, not the whole

When the Superintendent directs a thicker slab over part of a floor, the slab depth in the bill is already measured and paid. The variation is the extra: the thickened area times the depth added. The same goes for reinforcement: only the bar schedule addendum, not the whole schedule again.

Example. Measuring the whole 260 mm depth would pay the first 200 mm twice.
Thickened area, 6.00 × 4.5027.00 m²
Depth added, 200 to 260 mm, m0.06
Extra concrete, m³1.62
2 / 3

Bill rate or agreed rate

AS 4000 values a variation in an order of preference: a price agreed beforehand, then the contract's own rates where they apply, then reasonable rates. A bill rate applies only where the work is of the same kind and done under the same conditions. Concrete and reinforcement in a thickening are the same work as in the slab. A 50 mm step in the soffit is not a full-height slab edge, so the edge formwork rate does not fit it, and a rate is agreed instead.

Example. Write down why each rate was chosen. The Superintendent will ask, and the answer is the line in the bill or the agreement.
3 / 3

Margin once, GST not at all

The Annexure may set a margin for off-site overheads and profit on a variation. It goes on once, on the total of the components. GST is not part of a variation's value: variations, like bill lines, are excluding GST. The tax is added once, at the foot of the payment claim.

Example. Margin 12 % of $2,100.00 is $252.00. The 12 % is that contract's Annexure choice, not a law.
$5701+$9202+$6103+$2524$2,3525
  • 1 Concrete at the bill rate
  • 2 Reinforcement at the bill rate
  • 3 Formwork and trimming, agreed rates
  • 4 Margin, 12 %
  • 5 Variation value

Price a slab thickening

Another job: a plant room floor thickened under a directed change.

Not to scale
The problem
  • Area thickened 6.4 m × 4.5 m, from 200 to 250 mm: 0.05 m added.
  • Bill rates: concrete $305.00 per m³, reinforcement $2,410.00 per t. Bar schedule addendum 360 kg.
  • Agreed rates: step formwork $35.20 per m round the thickened area; $76.00 for each of 4 new penetrations.
  • Annexure margin 12%.
Thickened area, m²28.8
Depth added, m0.05
Extra concrete, m³?
Thickened area, m²28.8
Depth added, m0.05
Extra concrete, m³1.44
Step 1 of 4

Extra concrete

Thickened area times the depth added. How many m³?

6.4 m × 4.5 m × 0.05 m = 1.44 m³.

Step 2 of 4

Components at bill rates

Concrete and reinforcement at the bill rates. What do the two come to?

Concrete 1.44 m³ × $305.00 = $439.20. Reinforcement 360 kg is 0.36 t × $2,410.00 = $867.60. Together $1,306.80.

$1,307$767
  • Bill rates $1,307
  • Step formwork $767
  • Penetrations $304
$1,307$767
  • Bill rates $1,307
  • Step formwork $767
  • Penetrations $304
Step 3 of 4

Before the margin

Add the step formwork and the penetrations at the agreed rates. What is the variation before the margin?

Girth 21.8 m × $35.20 = $767.36. Penetrations 4 × $76.00 = $304.00. With $1,306.80 that is $2,378.16.

$2,3781+$2852?3
  • 1 Before the margin
  • 2 Margin
  • 3 Variation value
$2,3781+$2852$2,6643
  • 1 Before the margin
  • 2 Margin
  • 3 Variation value
Step 4 of 4

Variation value

Add the Annexure margin. What is the value of the variation, excluding GST?

$2,378.16 plus 12% is $2,663.54, excluding GST.

In short. Measure the extra only. Bill rates where the work is the same, agreed rates where it is not. Margin once, GST later.

Check yourself

Question 1 of 3

A direction adds a 50 mm soffit step. The bill has edge formwork at 250 mm high. Which rate do you use?

  • The height is part of the description. A different height is different work.

  • Where no contract rate applies, a rate is agreed or a reasonable rate is used.

  • Formwork is a measured item in this bill.

  • Scaling is a way to reach an agreed rate, not the bill rate itself.

Question 2 of 3

Where does GST go when you price a variation?

  • Variations are excluding GST, like the bill.

  • That still puts it in the variation.

  • The tax follows the claim, not each line.

  • Construction work is a taxable supply. The tax is added on the claim.

Question 3 of 3

Components at bill and agreed rates total $5,240.00. The Annexure margin is 8 %. What is the variation value, excluding GST?

$5,240.00 × 1.08 = $5,659.20.