OpenConstruction Academy
Sign in / Register
EN

Theory before task 5 · 7 min

Contract penalty after a hindrance: § 11 VOB/B

The penalty letter

After this lecture you can

  1. Say when a penalty for a date is due.
  2. Move the date by the extensions and count delay.
  3. Check the reservation at acceptance and the cap.
1 / 3

No delay, no penalty

A penalty for missing a date is due only when the contractor is in delay (§ 339 BGB). Extensions of time move the date, so days inside the extended period are not delay. A client who counts from the original date counts days it caused itself.

Example. Due 1 June, extended by 10 working days, finished 4 working days after the new date: 4 days of penalty.
Client's count
€14 (€10 + €4)
Delay
€4
2 / 3

Acceptance and the cap

After acceptance the client can claim the penalty only if it reserved it at acceptance (§ 11 (4)). In standard terms the total may not exceed 5 % of the contract sum; the cap is a ceiling, not the amount.

Example. A deduction at the full cap for four days late is the cap misread as a price.
Common mistake

Accepting the deduction

The deduction arrives with the payment and looks final. Check the reservation, move the date, count the days the contract counts, and answer in writing with the amount you accept.

Example. Net sum €800,000, 0.2 % a day: each day is €1,600.00; four days are €6,400.00, not the €32,000.00 cap.

Penalty after an extension

Different numbers from your task.

Not to scale
The problem
  • Net contract sum €800,000; 0.2 % per working day, at most 5 %.
  • 4 working days of delay after the extended date.
Step 1 of 1

Penalty

What penalty is owed?

€800,000 × 0.2 % × 4 = €6,400.00.

In short. Move the date, count the delay, apply the daily rate, check the cap.

Check yourself

Question 1 of 3

The client did not reserve the penalty at acceptance. Penalty?

  • Right: § 11 (4).

  • There is no halving.

  • The reservation was needed at acceptance.

Question 2 of 3

What does the 5 % cap do?

  • Right.

  • It is a ceiling.

  • The daily rate is separate.

Question 3 of 3

Net sum €500,000, 0.2 % a day, 3 days late after the extended date. Penalty?

500,000 × 0.2 % × 3 = 3,000.

Read the source

Free official texts. The lecture cites clause numbers and puts the rules in its own words.